How do you efficiently generate a list of K non-repeating integers between 0 and an upper bound N [duplicate] How do you efficiently generate a list of K non-repeating integers between 0 and an upper bound N [duplicate] arrays arrays

How do you efficiently generate a list of K non-repeating integers between 0 and an upper bound N [duplicate]


In The Art of Computer Programming, Volume 2: Seminumerical Algorithms, Third Edition, Knuth describes the following selection sampling algorithm:

Algorithm S (Selection sampling technique). To select n records at random from a set of N, where 0 < n ≤ N.

S1. [Initialize.] Set t ← 0, m ← 0. (During this algorithm, m represents the number of records selected so far, and t is the total number of input records that we have dealt with.)

S2. [Generate U.] Generate a random number U, uniformly distributed between zero and one.

S3. [Test.] If (N – t)U ≥ n – m, go to step S5.

S4. [Select.] Select the next record for the sample, and increase m and t by 1. If m < n, go to step S2; otherwise the sample is complete and the algorithm terminates.

S5. [Skip.] Skip the next record (do not include it in the sample), increase t by 1, and go back to step S2.

An implementation may be easier to follow than the description. Here is a Common Lisp implementation that select n random members from a list:

(defun sample-list (n list &optional (length (length list)) result)  (cond ((= length 0) result)        ((< (* length (random 1.0)) n)         (sample-list (1- n) (cdr list) (1- length)                      (cons (car list) result)))        (t (sample-list n (cdr list) (1- length) result))))

And here is an implementation that does not use recursion, and which works with all kinds of sequences:

(defun sample (n sequence)  (let ((length (length sequence))        (result (subseq sequence 0 n)))    (loop       with m = 0       for i from 0 and u = (random 1.0)       do (when (< (* (- length i) u)                    (- n m))            (setf (elt result m) (elt sequence i))            (incf m))       until (= m n))    result))


The random module from Python library makes it extremely easy and effective:

from random import sampleprint sample(xrange(N), K)

sample function returns a list of K unique elements chosen from the given sequence.
xrange is a "list emulator", i.e. it behaves like a list of consecutive numbers without creating it in memory, which makes it super-fast for tasks like this one.


It is actually possible to do this in space proportional to the number of elements selected, rather than the size of the set you're selecting from, regardless of what proportion of the total set you're selecting. You do this by generating a random permutation, then selecting from it like this:

Pick a block cipher, such as TEA or XTEA. Use XOR folding to reduce the block size to the smallest power of two larger than the set you're selecting from. Use the random seed as the key to the cipher. To generate an element n in the permutation, encrypt n with the cipher. If the output number is not in your set, encrypt that. Repeat until the number is inside the set. On average you will have to do less than two encryptions per generated number. This has the added benefit that if your seed is cryptographically secure, so is your entire permutation.

I wrote about this in much more detail here.