When to use @QueryParam vs @PathParam

REST may not be a standard as such, but reading up on general REST documentation and blog posts should give you some guidelines for a good way to structure API URLs. Most rest APIs tend to only have resource names and resource IDs in the path. Such as:

/departments/{dept}/employees/{id}

Some REST APIs use query strings for filtering, pagination and sorting, but Since REST isn't a strict standard I'd recommend checking some REST APIs out there such as github and stackoverflow and see what could work well for your use case.

I'd recommend putting any required parameters in the path, and any optional parameters should certainly be query string parameters. Putting optional parameters in the path will end up getting really messy when trying to write URL handlers that match different combinations.

This is what I do.

If there is a scenario to retrieve a record based on id, for example you need to get the details of the employee whose id is 15, then you can have resource with @PathParam.

GET /employee/{id}

If there is a scenario where you need to get the details of all employees but only 10 at a time, you may use query param

GET /employee?start=1&size=10

This says that starting employee id 1 get ten records.

To summarize, use @PathParam for retrieval based on id. User @QueryParam for filter or if you have any fixed list of options that user can pass.

I think that if the parameter identifies a specific entity you should use a path variable. For example, to get all the posts on my blog I request

GET: myserver.com/myblog/posts

to get the post with id = 123, I would request

GET: myserver.com/myblog/posts/123

but to filter my list of posts, and get all posts since Jan 1, 2013, I would request

GET: myserver.com/myblog/posts?since=2013-01-01

In the first example "posts" identifies a specific entity (the entire collection of blog posts). In the second example, "123" also represents a specific entity (a single blog post). But in the last example, the parameter "since=2013-01-01" is a request to filter the posts collection not a specific entity. Pagination and ordering would be another good example, i.e.

GET: myserver.com/myblog/posts?page=2&order=backward

Hope that helps. :-)