ScheduledExecutorService Exception handling ScheduledExecutorService Exception handling multithreading multithreading

ScheduledExecutorService Exception handling


tl;dr

Any exception escaping your run method halts all further work, without notice.

Always use a try-catch within your run method. Try to recover if you want scheduled activity to continue.

@Overridepublic void run (){    try {        doChore();    } catch ( Exception e ) {         logger.error( "Caught exception in ScheduledExecutorService. StackTrace:\n" + t.getStackTrace() );    }}

The Problem

The question refers to the critical trick with a ScheduledExecutorService: Any thrown exception or error reaching the executor causes the executor to halt. No more invocations on the Runnable, no more work done. This work stoppage happens silently, you'll not be informed. This naughty-language blog posting entertainingly narrates the hard way to learn about this behavior.

The Solution

The answer by yegor256 and the answer by arun_suresh both seem to be basically correct. Two issues with those answers:

  • Catch errors as well as exceptions
  • A bit complicated

Errors and Exceptions ?

In Java we normally catch only exceptions, not errors. But in this special case of ScheduledExecutorService, failing to catch either will mean a work stoppage. So you may want to catch both. I'm not 100% sure about this, not knowing fully the implications of catching all errors. Please correct me if needed.

One reason to catch errors as well as exceptions might involve the use of libraries within your task. See the comment by jannis.

One way to catch both exceptions and errors is to catch their superclass, Throwable for an example.

} catch ( Throwable t ) {

…rather than…

} catch ( Exception e ) {

Simplest Approach: Just Add a Try-Catch

But both answers are a bit complicated. Just for the record, I'll show the simplest solution:

Always wrap your Runnable's code in a Try-Catch to catch any and all exceptions and errors.

Lambda Syntax

With a lambda (in Java 8 and later).

final Runnable someChoreRunnable = () -> {    try {        doChore();    } catch ( Throwable t ) {  // Catch Throwable rather than Exception (a subclass).        logger.error( "Caught exception in ScheduledExecutorService. StackTrace:\n" + t.getStackTrace() );    }};

Old-Fashioned Syntax

The old-fashioned way, before lambdas.

final Runnable someChoreRunnable = new Runnable(){    @Override    public void run ()    {        try {            doChore();        } catch ( Throwable t ) {  // Catch Throwable rather than Exception (a subclass).            logger.error( "Caught exception in ScheduledExecutorService. StackTrace:\n" + t.getStackTrace() );        }    }};

In Every Runnable/Callable

Regardless of a ScheduledExecutorService, it seems sensible to me to always use a general try-catch( Exception† e ) in any run method of a Runnable. Ditto for any call method of a Callable.


Complete example code

In real work, I would likely define the Runnable separately rather than nested. But this makes for neat all-in-one example.

package com.basilbourque.example;import java.time.ZoneId;import java.time.ZonedDateTime;import java.util.concurrent.Executors;import java.util.concurrent.ScheduledExecutorService;import java.util.concurrent.ScheduledFuture;import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;/** *  Demo `ScheduledExecutorService` */public class App {    public static void main ( String[] args ) {        App app = new App();        app.doIt();    }    private void doIt () {        // Demonstrate a working scheduled executor service.        // Run, and watch the console for 20 seconds.        System.out.println( "BASIL - Start." );        ScheduledExecutorService scheduler = Executors.newSingleThreadScheduledExecutor();        ScheduledFuture < ? > handle =                scheduler.scheduleWithFixedDelay( new Runnable() {                    public void run () {                        try {                            // doChore ;   // Do business logic.                            System.out.println( "Now: " + ZonedDateTime.now( ZoneId.systemDefault() ) );  // Report current moment.                        } catch ( Exception e ) {                            // … handle exception/error. Trap any unexpected exception here rather to stop it reaching and shutting-down the scheduled executor service.                            // logger.error( "Caught exception in ScheduledExecutorService. StackTrace:\n" + e.getStackTrace() );                        }   // End of try-catch.                    }   // End of `run` method.                } , 0 , 2 , TimeUnit.SECONDS );        // Wait a long moment, for background thread to do some work.        try {            Thread.sleep( TimeUnit.SECONDS.toMillis( 20 ) );        } catch ( InterruptedException e ) {            e.printStackTrace();        }        // Time is up. Kill the executor service and its thread pool.        scheduler.shutdown();        System.out.println( "BASIL - Done." );    }}

When run.

BASIL - Start.

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:01.423286-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:03.449178-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:05.450107-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:07.450586-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:09.456076-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:11.456872-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:13.461944-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:15.463837-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:17.469218-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

Now: 2018-04-10T16:46:19.473935-07:00[America/Los_Angeles]

BASIL - Done.


† Or perhaps Throwable instead of Exception to catch Error objects too.


You should use the ScheduledFuture object returned by your scheduler.scheduleWithFixedDelay(...) like so :

ScheduledExecutorService scheduler = Executors.newSingleThreadScheduledExecutor();ScheduledFuture<?> handle =        scheduler.scheduleWithFixedDelay(new Runnable() {             public void run() {                  throw new RuntimeException("foo");             }        }, 1, 10, TimeUnit.SECONDS);// Create and Start an exception handler thread// pass the "handle" object to the thread// Inside the handler thread do :....try {  handle.get();} catch (ExecutionException e) {  Exception rootException = e.getCause();}


Old question but the accepted answer doesn't give explanations and provides a poor example and the most upvoted answer is right on some points but finally encourages you to add catch exceptions in every Runnable.run() method.
I disagree because :

  • it is not neat : not standard for a task to catch its own exceptions.
  • it is not robust : a new Runnable subclass could forget to perform the exception catch and the failover associated.
  • it defeats the low coupling promoted by tasks since that couples the tasks to execute with the way of handling the task result.
  • it mixes responsibilities : that is not the task responsibility to handle the exception or to communicate the exception to the caller. A task is something to execute.

I think that the exception propagation should be performed by the ExecutorService framework and actually it offers that feature.
Besides, trying to be too clever by trying to short-circuiting the ExecutorService way of working is not a good idea either : the framework may evolve and you want to use it in a standard way.
At last, letting the ExecutorService framework to make its job doesn't mean necessarily halting the subsequent invocations task.
If a scheduled task encounters an issue, that is the caller responsibility to re-schedule or not the task according to the issue cause.
Each layer has its its responsibilities. Keeping these make code both clear and maintainable.


ScheduledFuture.get() : the right API to catch exceptions and errors occurred in the task

ScheduledExecutorService.scheduleWithFixedDelay()/scheduleAtFixRate() state in their specification :

If any execution of the task encounters an exception, subsequent executions are suppressed. Otherwise, the task will only terminate via cancellation or termination of the executor.

It means that ScheduledFuture.get() doesn't return at each scheduled invocation but that it returns for the last invocation of the task, that is a task cancelation : caused by ScheduledFuture.cancel() or a exception thrown in the task.
So handling the ScheduledFuture return to capture the exception with ScheduledFuture.get() looks right :

  try {    future.get();  } catch (InterruptedException e) {    // ... to handle  } catch (ExecutionException e) {    // ... and unwrap the exception OR the error that caused the issue    Throwable cause = e.getCause();         }

Example with the default behavior : halting the scheduling if one of the task execution encounters an issue

It executes a task that for the third executions thrown an exception and terminates the scheduling. In some scenarios, we want that.

import java.util.concurrent.ExecutionException;import java.util.concurrent.Executors;import java.util.concurrent.Future;import java.util.concurrent.ScheduledExecutorService;import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;import java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicInteger;public class ScheduledExecutorServiceWithException {  public static void main(String[] args) {    ScheduledExecutorService executor = Executors.newScheduledThreadPool(2);    // variable used to thrown an error at the 3rd task invocation    AtomicInteger countBeforeError = new AtomicInteger(3);    // boolean allowing to leave the client to halt the scheduling task or not after a failure    Future<?> futureA = executor        .scheduleWithFixedDelay(new MyRunnable(countBeforeError), 1, 2, TimeUnit.SECONDS);    try {      System.out.println("before get()");      futureA.get(); // will return only if canceled      System.out.println("after get()");    } catch (InterruptedException e) {      // handle that : halt or no    } catch (ExecutionException e) {      System.out.println("exception caught :" + e.getCause());    }    // shutdown the executorservice    executor.shutdown();  }  private static class MyRunnable implements Runnable {    private final AtomicInteger invocationDone;    public MyRunnable(AtomicInteger invocationDone) {      this.invocationDone = invocationDone;    }    @Override    public void run() {      System.out.println(Thread.currentThread().getName() + ", execution");      if (invocationDone.decrementAndGet() == 0) {        throw new IllegalArgumentException("ohhh an Exception in MyRunnable");      }    }  }}

Output :

before get()pool-1-thread-1, executionpool-1-thread-1, executionpool-1-thread-1, executionexception caught :java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: ohhh an Exception in MyRunnable

Example with the possibility to go on the scheduling if one of the task execution encounters an issue

It executes a task that throws an exception at the two first executions and throws an error at the third one. We can see that the client of the tasks can choose to halt or not the scheduling : here I go on in cases of exception and I stop in case of error.

import java.util.concurrent.ExecutionException;import java.util.concurrent.Executors;import java.util.concurrent.Future;import java.util.concurrent.ScheduledExecutorService;import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;import java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicInteger;public class ScheduledExecutorServiceWithException {  public static void main(String[] args) {    ScheduledExecutorService executor = Executors.newScheduledThreadPool(2);    // variable used to thrown an error at the 3rd task invocation    AtomicInteger countBeforeError = new AtomicInteger(3);    // boolean allowing to leave the client to halt the scheduling task or not after a failure    boolean mustHalt = true;    do {      Future<?> futureA = executor              .scheduleWithFixedDelay(new MyRunnable(countBeforeError), 1, 2, TimeUnit.SECONDS);      try {        futureA.get(); // will return only if canceled      } catch (InterruptedException e) {        // handle that : halt or not halt      } catch (ExecutionException e) {        if (e.getCause() instanceof Error) {          System.out.println("I halt in case of Error");          mustHalt = true;        } else {          System.out.println("I reschedule in case of Exception");          mustHalt = false;        }      }    }    while (!mustHalt);    // shutdown the executorservice    executor.shutdown();  }  private static class MyRunnable implements Runnable {    private final AtomicInteger invocationDone;    public MyRunnable(AtomicInteger invocationDone) {      this.invocationDone = invocationDone;    }    @Override    public void run() {      System.out.println(Thread.currentThread().getName() + ", execution");      if (invocationDone.decrementAndGet() == 0) {        throw new Error("ohhh an Error in MyRunnable");      } else {        throw new IllegalArgumentException("ohhh an Exception in MyRunnable");      }    }  }}

Output :

pool-1-thread-1, executionI reschedule in case of Exceptionpool-1-thread-1, executionI reschedule in case of Exceptionpool-1-thread-2, executionI halt in case of Error