Anyone using Python for embedded projects? [closed]

We use python in quite a lot of embedded boards with ARM processors and 16 MB of RAM (running linux).

It works really well and is really easy to make custom code quickly - one of the strong points of python.

As for reliability of the code - we try to have 100% test coverage. Writing tests with python is very quick and it gives you a wonderful feeling of confidence. We use twisted trial to run the tests and report on coverage, but there are many other tools available.

In my experience python + tests is more reliable and much quicker to write than any other alternatives.

The only downsides for embedded work is that sometimes python can be slow and sometimes it uses a lot of memory (relatively speaking). This hasn't causes us a show stopping problem yet, and python is quite easy to profile for both speed and memory if it becomes a problem.

pychecker is a very useful too also which will catch quite a lot of common errors.

BTW, see this blog post: "Type inference for Python" for an interesting discussion of type inference and static typing, including links to some Guido van Rossum blog posts describing adding optional static typing to Python.

I agree with Bruce Eckel that one is better off practicing "strong testing" than relying on strong typing. I think that applies equally well to embedded development.

Personally, I've worked on some of the software that runs in the device used by BusRadio. It's an example of an embedded project built on Twisted and Python. The device is an embedded XScale processor running a debian-derived distribution, so it might not meet certain definitions of "embedded", but it is pretty dang small: it fits into the dashboard of a school bus.

There were some interesting issues with using Python with large libraries - the interpreter can take quite a while to start up and load all the code for Twisted on a really slow chip, and some things needed special-case optimizations. However, at no point was the dynamic nature of Python a problem. The software in question certainly wasn't perfect, but at least when using Twisted, a simple programming error will not "bring the whole application down". A traceback will get logged, and processing continues.

So, if you're in an embedded environment sufficiently unconstrained that you can use Python in the first place, it's no different than developing "regular" programs (games, desktop applications, web apps). You don't need static typing there, and you don't need it here either.