Finding the exponent of n = 2**x using bitwise operations [logarithm in base 2 of n] Finding the exponent of n = 2**x using bitwise operations [logarithm in base 2 of n] python python

Finding the exponent of n = 2**x using bitwise operations [logarithm in base 2 of n]


"language agnostic" and worrying about performance are pretty much incompatible concepts.

Most modern processors have a CLZ instruction, "count leading zeros". In GCC you can get to it with __builtin_clz(x) (which also produces reasonable, if not the fastest, code for targets that lack clz). Note that this CLZ is undefined for zero, so you'll need an extra branch to catch that case if it matters in your application.

In CELT ( http://celt-codec.org ) the branchless CLZ we use for compliers lacking a CLZ was written by Timothy B. Terriberry:

int ilog(uint32 _v){  int ret;  int m;  ret=!!_v;  m=!!(_v&0xFFFF0000)<<4;  _v>>=m;  ret|=m;  m=!!(_v&0xFF00)<<3;  _v>>=m;  ret|=m;  m=!!(_v&0xF0)<<2;  _v>>=m;  ret|=m;  m=!!(_v&0xC)<<1;  _v>>=m;  ret|=m;  ret+=!!(_v&0x2);  return ret;}

(The comments indicate that this was found to be faster than a branching version and a lookup table based version)

But if performance is that critical you probably shouldn't be implementing this part of your code in python.


Short answer

As far as python is concerned:

  • The fastest method of all to find the exponent of 2**x is by looking up in a dictionary whose hashes are the powers of 2 (see "hashlookup" in the code)
  • The fastest bitwise method is the one called "unrolled_bitwise".
  • Both previous methods have well-defined (but extensible) upper limits. The fastest method without hard-coded upper limits (which scales up as far as python can handle numbers) is "log_e".

Preliminary notes

  1. All speed measurements below have been obtained via timeit.Timer.repeat(testn, cycles) where testn was set to 3 and cycles was automatically adjusted by the script to obtain times in the range of seconds (note: there was a bug in this auto-adjusting mechanism that has been fixed on 18/02/2010).
  2. Not all methods can scale, this is why I did not test all functions for the various powers of 2
  3. I did not manage to get some of the proposed methods to work (the function returns a wrong result). I did not yet have tiem to do a step-by-step debugging session: I included the code (commented) just in case somebody spots the mistake by inspection (or want to perform the debug themselves)

Results

func(25)**

hashlookup:          0.13s     100%lookup:              0.15s     109%stringcount:         0.29s     220%unrolled_bitwise:    0.36s     272%log_e:               0.60s     450%bitcounter:          0.64s     479%log_2:               0.69s     515%ilog:                0.81s     609%bitwise:             1.10s     821%olgn:                1.42s    1065%

func(231)**

hashlookup:          0.11s     100%unrolled_bitwise:    0.26s     229%log_e:               0.30s     268%stringcount:         0.30s     270%log_2:               0.34s     301%ilog:                0.41s     363%bitwise:             0.87s     778%olgn:                1.02s     912%bitcounter:          1.42s    1264%

func(2128)**

hashlookup:     0.01s     100%stringcount:    0.03s     264%log_e:          0.04s     315%log_2:          0.04s     383%olgn:           0.18s    1585%bitcounter:     1.41s   12393%

func(21024)**

log_e:          0.00s     100%log_2:          0.01s     118%stringcount:    0.02s     354%olgn:           0.03s     707%bitcounter:     1.73s   37695%

Code

import math, sysdef stringcount(v):    """mac"""        return len(bin(v)) - 3def log_2(v):    """mac"""        return int(round(math.log(v, 2), 0)) # 2**101 generates 100.999999999def log_e(v):    """bp on mac"""        return int(round(math.log(v)/0.69314718055994529, 0))  # 0.69 == log(2)def bitcounter(v):    """John Y on mac"""    r = 0    while v > 1 :        v >>= 1        r += 1    return rdef olgn(n) :    """outis"""    if n < 1:        return -1    low = 0    high = sys.getsizeof(n)*8 # not the best upper-bound guesstimate, but...    while True:        mid = (low+high)//2        i = n >> mid        if i == 1:            return mid        if i == 0:            high = mid-1        else:            low = mid+1def hashlookup(v):    """mac on brone -- limit: v < 2**131"""#    def prepareTable(max_log2=130) :#        hash_table = {}#        for p in range(1, max_log2) :#            hash_table[2**p] = p#        return hash_table    global hash_table    return hash_table[v] def lookup(v):    """brone -- limit: v < 2**11"""#    def prepareTable(max_log2=10) :#        log2s_table=[0]*((1<<max_log2)+1)#        for i in range(max_log2+1):#            log2s_table[1<<i]=i#        return tuple(log2s_table)    global log2s_table    return log2s_table[v]def bitwise(v):    """Mark Byers -- limit: v < 2**32"""    b = (0x2, 0xC, 0xF0, 0xFF00, 0xFFFF0000)    S = (1, 2, 4, 8, 16)    r = 0    for i in range(4, -1, -1) :        if (v & b[i]) :            v >>= S[i];            r |= S[i];    return rdef unrolled_bitwise(v):    """x4u on Mark Byers -- limit:   v < 2**33"""    r = 0;    if v > 0xffff :         v >>= 16        r = 16;    if v > 0x00ff :        v >>=  8        r += 8;    if v > 0x000f :        v >>=  4        r += 4;    if v > 0x0003 :         v >>=  2        r += 2;    return r + (v >> 1)def ilog(v):    """Gregory Maxwell - (Original code: B. Terriberry) -- limit: v < 2**32"""    ret = 1    m = (not not v & 0xFFFF0000) << 4;    v >>= m;    ret |= m;    m = (not not v & 0xFF00) << 3;    v >>= m;    ret |= m;    m = (not not v & 0xF0) << 2;    v >>= m;    ret |= m;    m = (not not v & 0xC) << 1;    v >>= m;    ret |= m;    ret += (not not v & 0x2);    return ret - 1;# following table is equal to "return hashlookup.prepareTable()" hash_table = {...} # numbers have been cut out to avoid cluttering the post# following table is equal to "return lookup.prepareTable()" - cached for speedlog2s_table = (...) # numbers have been cut out to avoid cluttering the post


There is a page with a lot of these types of tricks and hacks. It's written for C, but many of them should work in Python too (though the performance will obviously be different). The bit you want is here and onwards.

You could try this for example:

register unsigned int r = 0; // result of log2(v) will go herefor (i = 4; i >= 0; i--) // unroll for speed...{  if (v & b[i])  {    v >>= S[i];    r |= S[i];  } }

That looks like it could be converted to Python quite easily.