Flattening a shallow list in Python [duplicate] Flattening a shallow list in Python [duplicate] python python

Flattening a shallow list in Python [duplicate]


If you're just looking to iterate over a flattened version of the data structure and don't need an indexable sequence, consider itertools.chain and company.

>>> list_of_menuitems = [['image00', 'image01'], ['image10'], []]>>> import itertools>>> chain = itertools.chain(*list_of_menuitems)>>> print(list(chain))['image00', 'image01', 'image10']

It will work on anything that's iterable, which should include Django's iterable QuerySets, which it appears that you're using in the question.

Edit: This is probably as good as a reduce anyway, because reduce will have the same overhead copying the items into the list that's being extended. chain will only incur this (same) overhead if you run list(chain) at the end.

Meta-Edit: Actually, it's less overhead than the question's proposed solution, because you throw away the temporary lists you create when you extend the original with the temporary.

Edit: As J.F. Sebastian says itertools.chain.from_iterable avoids the unpacking and you should use that to avoid * magic, but the timeit app shows negligible performance difference.


You almost have it! The way to do nested list comprehensions is to put the for statements in the same order as they would go in regular nested for statements.

Thus, this

for inner_list in outer_list:    for item in inner_list:        ...

corresponds to

[... for inner_list in outer_list for item in inner_list]

So you want

[image for menuitem in list_of_menuitems for image in menuitem]


@S.Lott: You inspired me to write a timeit app.

I figured it would also vary based on the number of partitions (number of iterators within the container list) -- your comment didn't mention how many partitions there were of the thirty items. This plot is flattening a thousand items in every run, with varying number of partitions. The items are evenly distributed among the partitions.

Flattening Comparison

Code (Python 2.6):

#!/usr/bin/env python2.6"""Usage: %prog item_count"""from __future__ import print_functionimport collectionsimport itertoolsimport operatorfrom timeit import Timerimport sysimport matplotlib.pyplot as pyplotdef itertools_flatten(iter_lst):    return list(itertools.chain(*iter_lst))def itertools_iterable_flatten(iter_iter):    return list(itertools.chain.from_iterable(iter_iter))def reduce_flatten(iter_lst):    return reduce(operator.add, map(list, iter_lst))def reduce_lambda_flatten(iter_lst):    return reduce(operator.add, map(lambda x: list(x), [i for i in iter_lst]))def comprehension_flatten(iter_lst):    return list(item for iter_ in iter_lst for item in iter_)METHODS = ['itertools', 'itertools_iterable', 'reduce', 'reduce_lambda',           'comprehension']def _time_test_assert(iter_lst):    """Make sure all methods produce an equivalent value.    :raise AssertionError: On any non-equivalent value."""    callables = (globals()[method + '_flatten'] for method in METHODS)    results = [callable(iter_lst) for callable in callables]    if not all(result == results[0] for result in results[1:]):        raise AssertionErrordef time_test(partition_count, item_count_per_partition, test_count=10000):    """Run flatten methods on a list of :param:`partition_count` iterables.    Normalize results over :param:`test_count` runs.    :return: Mapping from method to (normalized) microseconds per pass.    """    iter_lst = [[dict()] * item_count_per_partition] * partition_count    print('Partition count:    ', partition_count)    print('Items per partition:', item_count_per_partition)    _time_test_assert(iter_lst)    test_str = 'flatten(%r)' % iter_lst    result_by_method = {}    for method in METHODS:        setup_str = 'from test import %s_flatten as flatten' % method        t = Timer(test_str, setup_str)        per_pass = test_count * t.timeit(number=test_count) / test_count        print('%20s: %.2f usec/pass' % (method, per_pass))        result_by_method[method] = per_pass    return result_by_methodif __name__ == '__main__':    if len(sys.argv) != 2:        raise ValueError('Need a number of items to flatten')    item_count = int(sys.argv[1])    partition_counts = []    pass_times_by_method = collections.defaultdict(list)    for partition_count in xrange(1, item_count):        if item_count % partition_count != 0:            continue        items_per_partition = item_count / partition_count        result_by_method = time_test(partition_count, items_per_partition)        partition_counts.append(partition_count)        for method, result in result_by_method.iteritems():            pass_times_by_method[method].append(result)    for method, pass_times in pass_times_by_method.iteritems():        pyplot.plot(partition_counts, pass_times, label=method)    pyplot.legend()    pyplot.title('Flattening Comparison for %d Items' % item_count)    pyplot.xlabel('Number of Partitions')    pyplot.ylabel('Microseconds')    pyplot.show()

Edit: Decided to make it community wiki.

Note: METHODS should probably be accumulated with a decorator, but I figure it'd be easier for people to read this way.


matomo