How to use concerns in Rails 4
So I found it out by myself. It is actually a pretty simple but powerful concept. It has to do with code reuse as in the example below. Basically, the idea is to extract common and / or context specific chunks of code in order to clean up the models and avoid them getting too fat and messy.
As an example, I'll put one well known pattern, the taggable pattern:
# app/models/product.rbclass Product include Taggable ...end# app/models/concerns/taggable.rb# notice that the file name has to match the module name # (applying Rails conventions for autoloading)module Taggable extend ActiveSupport::Concern included do has_many :taggings, as: :taggable has_many :tags, through: :taggings class_attribute :tag_limit end def tags_string tags.map(&:name).join(', ') end def tags_string=(tag_string) tag_names = tag_string.to_s.split(', ') tag_names.each do |tag_name| tags.build(name: tag_name) end end # methods defined here are going to extend the class, not the instance of it module ClassMethods def tag_limit(value) self.tag_limit_value = value end endend
So following the Product sample, you can add Taggable to any class you desire and share its functionality.
This is pretty well explained by DHH:
In Rails 4, we’re going to invite programmers to use concerns with the default app/models/concerns and app/controllers/concerns directories that are automatically part of the load path. Together with the ActiveSupport::Concern wrapper, it’s just enough support to make this light-weight factoring mechanism shine.
I have been reading about using model concerns to skin-nize fat models as well as DRY up your model codes. Here is an explanation with examples:
1) DRYing up model codes
Consider a Article model, a Event model and a Comment model. An article or an event has many comments. A comment belongs to either Article or Event.
Traditionally, the models may look like this:
Comment Model:
class Comment < ActiveRecord::Base belongs_to :commentable, polymorphic: trueend
Article Model:
class Article < ActiveRecord::Base has_many :comments, as: :commentable def find_first_comment comments.first(created_at DESC) end def self.least_commented #return the article with least number of comments endend
Event Model
class Event < ActiveRecord::Base has_many :comments, as: :commentable def find_first_comment comments.first(created_at DESC) end def self.least_commented #returns the event with least number of comments endend
As we can notice, there is a significant piece of code common to both Event and Article. Using concerns we can extract this common code in a separate module Commentable.
For this create a commentable.rb file in app/models/concerns.
module Commentable extend ActiveSupport::Concern included do has_many :comments, as: :commentable end # for the given article/event returns the first comment def find_first_comment comments.first(created_at DESC) end module ClassMethods def least_commented #returns the article/event which has the least number of comments end endend
And now your models look like this :
Comment Model:
class Comment < ActiveRecord::Base belongs_to :commentable, polymorphic: trueend
Article Model:
class Article < ActiveRecord::Base include Commentableend
Event Model:
class Event < ActiveRecord::Base include Commentableend
2) Skin-nizing Fat Models.
Consider a Event model. A event has many attenders and comments.
Typically, the event model might look like this
class Event < ActiveRecord::Base has_many :comments has_many :attenders def find_first_comment # for the given article/event returns the first comment end def find_comments_with_word(word) # for the given event returns an array of comments which contain the given word end def self.least_commented # finds the event which has the least number of comments end def self.most_attended # returns the event with most number of attendes end def has_attendee(attendee_id) # returns true if the event has the mentioned attendee endend
Models with many associations and otherwise have tendency to accumulate more and more code and become unmanageable. Concerns provide a way to skin-nize fat modules making them more modularized and easy to understand.
The above model can be refactored using concerns as below:Create a attendable.rb
and commentable.rb
file in app/models/concerns/event folder
attendable.rb
module Attendable extend ActiveSupport::Concern included do has_many :attenders end def has_attender(attender_id) # returns true if the event has the mentioned attendee end module ClassMethods def most_attended # returns the event with most number of attendes end endend
commentable.rb
module Commentable extend ActiveSupport::Concern included do has_many :comments end def find_first_comment # for the given article/event returns the first comment end def find_comments_with_word(word) # for the given event returns an array of comments which contain the given word end module ClassMethods def least_commented # finds the event which has the least number of comments end endend
And now using Concerns, your Event model reduces to
class Event < ActiveRecord::Base include Commentable include Attendableend
* While using concerns its advisable to go for 'domain' based grouping rather than 'technical' grouping. Domain Based grouping is like 'Commentable', 'Photoable', 'Attendable'. Technical grouping will mean 'ValidationMethods', 'FinderMethods' etc
It's worth to mention that using concerns is considered bad idea by many.
Some reasons:
- There is some dark magic happening behind the scenes - Concern is patching
include
method, there is a whole dependency handling system - way too much complexity for something that's trivial good old Ruby mixin pattern. - Your classes are no less dry. If you stuff 50 public methods in various modules and include them, your class still has 50 public methods, it's just that you hide that code smell, sort of put your garbage in the drawers.
- Codebase is actually harder to navigate with all those concerns around.
- Are you sure all members of your team have same understanding what should really substitute concern?
Concerns are easy way to shoot yourself in the leg, be careful with them.